⤴️-Paid Ad- Check advertising disclaimer here. Add your banner here.🔥
-
Posts
267 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Reputation Activity
-
⭐ aotegaoteg got a reaction from lalelulilo in order flow analysis
I have been backtesting nearly 10 years of historical data across different asset classes using Ninjatrader market replay data. What I'm about to describe may be controversial, but I have to say it: using order flow as a strategy does not work and provides no real edge.
I backtested the following order flow strategies using high-quality data:
Footprint Absorption Imbalance Delta Delta divergence Cumulative Volume Delta Volume Profile Iceberg Order block Market depth I can conclude that 90% of these strategies produced no meaningful results. After digging deeper to confirm this, I discovered changes that occurred in 2017 to the real-time streaming trading data distributed by the CME.
In 2017, the CME significantly altered order flow data through the introduction of the Market by Order MBO data format, which is now used by most retail traders and trading platforms. This new format changed how trading data is streamed to platforms. It's well documented that these changes obstructed the visibility of traditional order flow data compared to pre-MBO feeds.
The current MBO format obscures aggregated orders at price levels and provides only snapshots of executed trades. This masks resting orders, making footprint analysis and similar techniques far more complicated.
So why do many traders still try using order flow strategies for day trading if they're largely useless?
As I noted earlier, 90% of these strategies produced no meaningful results. The only ones I found with some potential edge are those focused on imbalances between bids and asks. Additionally, analyzing delta and cumulative volume delta can help spot traps and divergences in buying versus selling pressure. Other strategies, like absorption and iceberg orders, are simply not visible in the streaming data.
-
⭐ aotegaoteg got a reaction from Playr101 in Market replay data - backtestpods.com
The Market replay data provided by Ninjatrader is limited, where do you propose to find 5 years of data to tweak? also to be consistent and to build statistics of how well a strategy can perform over time, backtesting provides essential historical metrics across different market conditions and MT5 would not provide this because the data in MT5 is inconsistence, i would not touch MT5 with a barge pole
-
⭐ aotegaoteg reacted to ⭐ apmoo in ninZa.co Imbalance Volume Sensor
https://workupload.com/file/eEHBdCccSF9
tap the like button for me pls
Thanks
-
⭐ aotegaoteg reacted to ⭐ apmoo in ofcoursetrader.com
https://workupload.com/archive/dzGzvcVqBu
Thanks
-
-
⭐ aotegaoteg reacted to ⭐ apmoo in marketxero.com
Forgot to mention put any number in the machine id field.
Thanks
-
-
⭐ aotegaoteg reacted to ampf in tradingcoders.com
There was a previous post already of https://www.tradingcoders.com/ however the link has expired and don't know if these indicators were included or not
TCMirrorLines_NT8.zip TCSideBiasIndicators_NT8.zip
-
⭐ aotegaoteg reacted to ⭐ apmoo in quantvue.io
A couple more
https://workupload.com/archive/BQT3a8zqXY
Thanks
-
⭐ aotegaoteg got a reaction from eure in DYNOTRADING COUNTER STRIKE
you don't need dynotrading, just look for the supertrend indicator, good luck
-
-
⭐ aotegaoteg reacted to ⭐ apmoo in tradingfuturesnow.com/
https://workupload.com/file/hD4yhsg7tB8
Thanks
-
⭐ aotegaoteg reacted to alodante in tradingfuturesnow.com/
I bought a few month ago. Need to be fix.
https://workupload.com/archive/7cWprRuDvE
-
-
-
⭐ aotegaoteg got a reaction from babeonidi in [GET] @dvanced get soft+pdf+python
correct link https://www.mediafire.com/file/oomgv671n7rfic6/Advanced_GET_9.1_EOD_Dashboard_Edition_Work.rar/file -
-
⭐ aotegaoteg reacted to ⭐ Atomo12345 in Stock Ticker_2.41.3
https://www.ashkon.com/ts.html
Greetings.
-
⭐ aotegaoteg reacted to MarcusJ. in Sniper Auto Trader
Original files use under Ninjatrader Jack Sparrow..
SniperBar.zip SniperSlingshotv19.zip Recommended-Profit-Target-and-Stop-Loss.pdf
-
⭐ aotegaoteg got a reaction from MrAdmin in II VIP Membership - FREE upgrade for OLD and ACTIVE Members
I would appreciate to be upgraded to VIP Thank you
-
⭐ aotegaoteg reacted to ⭐ levelupdown in Can anybody educate best0rderflow.com trial indicator?
Hi here i am attaching the bestorderflow.com trial.
can anyone deobfuscate it and share?
https://best0rderflow.com/images/tri...rflowTRIAL.zip
replace 0 with o (alphabet o) in the url
-
⭐ aotegaoteg got a reaction from ⭐ tick in Binance ninja trader 8 connector
https://ninjacoding.net/ninjatrader/adapters/Binance -
⭐ aotegaoteg got a reaction from hybrid76 in Rightline trading EDU
https://www.sendspace.com/file/en4m4a
untest, provide your feedback
-
⭐ aotegaoteg got a reaction from ⭐ Azazel in Emini-Watch TradeStation
https://www.sendspace.com/file/fjsswb -
⭐ aotegaoteg got a reaction from khnco in Emini-Watch TradeStation
https://www.sendspace.com/file/fjsswb