Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • 1 month later...
Guest Jayman007
Posted
I don't think this EA requires education. The version posted above should work just fine.
  • 4 weeks later...
Posted
  Sneed said:
Yes, it did very well for me for a couple of months on my live account, then it lost all the the money it made in just 2 weeks. :((

 

I don't trust any of these eas. Everybody here has a good head and thinking, so trade manually. You can only trust your own trades.

  • 3 weeks later...
Guest Jayman007
Posted
  robotfx2 said:
any latest update for the fish forex robot ??

 

 

Running this EA on a live account with TDFX using .2 lot size it took a $2140 loss last week wiping out all profits this ea has made me in the past few months. I'm done with this EA. The R/R ratio is not worth it in the long term.

 

BEWARE- all it takes is your recovery trade to go bad and you lose many months of profit.

Posted

My understanding is that this robot has been replaced by the vendor due to poor performance. The new robot is called the "fisher" and has to be purchased separately even though you may have already paid for the "fish" robot previously. But, they do give a "discount" for people who have already purchased the "fish". The new robot does not trade as often, but I do not know if it is profitable...:|

 

  robotfx2 said:
any latest update for the fish forex robot ??
Guest Jayman007
Posted (edited)

Blah blah blah.... I paid for fish forex and I'm not about to hand over more cash for a fixed version. I wish I could even say I made the purchase price back but after a big loss it puts you in the negative. As for trade frequency, fish only places trade setups once a day 4 days of the week. That means you only have a possibility to win 80 pips (each pair of trades is 10 pip TP and 30 pip SL) if EVERY trade setup it makes hits and wins. But if any 1 trade loses, it opens a recovery trade at 3x the size and if that loses you have just lost months of wins. The R/R ratio is too out of wack and you really need to be careful of leaving this running during volatile times (ie big news).

 

I was trading it at .4 lot size with 3x recovery trade setting. When it lost the .4 lot trade it opened a 2 lot trade (5x when setting is 100% set at 3x) and hit the 100 pip SL to lose me $2000. So beware, the logic being used to determine recovery trade size is broken. I'm running a paid for copy of 1.64.

 

 

 

On another note, Rita also sells an EA called ForexGreenbot and I'm running an educated version of that and so far seems stable but it does have it's losses. Fortunately just 1 set of losses doesn't kill your account.

Edited by Jayman007
Posted

Yes, I lost money with both "fish" and "greenbot" (now being replaced by Quattro).

 

She claims she is making a profit with these, but I don't know how. I have tried them on multiple brokers. :(

 

 

  Jayman007 said:
Blah blah blah.... I paid for fish forex and I'm not about to hand over more cash for a fixed version. I wish I could even say I made the purchase price back but after a big loss it puts you in the negative. As for trade frequency, fish only places trade setups once a day 4 days of the week. That means you only have a possibility to win 80 pips (each pair of trades is 10 pip TP and 30 pip SL) if EVERY trade setup it makes hits and wins. But if any 1 trade loses, it opens a recovery trade at 3x the size and if that loses you have just lost months of wins. The R/R ratio is too out of wack and you really need to be careful of leaving this running during volatile times (ie big news).

 

I was trading it at .4 lot size with 3x recovery trade setting. When it lost the .4 lot trade it opened a 2 lot trade (5x when setting is 100% set at 3x) and hit the 100 pip SL to lose me $2000. So beware, the logic being used to determine recovery trade size is broken. I'm running a paid for copy of 1.64.

 

 

 

On another note, Rita also sells an EA called ForexGreenbot and I'm running an educated version of that and so far seems stable but it does have it's losses. Fortunately just 1 set of losses doesn't kill your account.

  • 1 month later...
Guest Jayman007
Posted
  san2x said:
Please reupload to 4shared or multiupload

i cant acsses depositfile

 

thank you

 

 

Here you go....

[spoiler=download link]

http://mir.cr/UZEZI6FJ

 

 

 

Just FYI, this is a terrible EA. I paid for this and after I took a HUGE loss I dropped it. Only a matter of time and it will kill you.

  • 2 months later...
Posted

I lost more money than I made with the "fish", but, I guess if it wins once in awhile, I will keep using it. Even if it blows my account some day.... :P

 

;)) =))

 

  musketeer said:
good for you :) and "time to time" is interesting approach...
Guest Jayman007
Posted
I too lost far more with this one than I ever made with it. Tossed it in the bin. Thanks Rita.
  • 2 weeks later...
  • 2 months later...
Posted
They are not pushing this bot too much because they came out with other bots since Fish, that include this strategy and a few others. Solomon, Lady, 4 Seasons... etc. Not that they trade much better, but, those are the newer products that they support.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



×
×
  • Create New...