dynastic

Yes sadly this is the same old story about Gann. The life long quest for holy grail which will keep the reader buying more cryptic magic puzzle books and courses for rest of his life. Thank you, I think you answered the question about Gann and why this so called 'best trader' should be avoided. Now for Ray and his Orb theory (cycle length can fluctuate with 1/6th range)... it is true cycle can fluctuate but I also call this trading book authors perfect "large margin for error" Ok, let's test his research about cycles. I think the orb theory should become apparent. Let us check his Gold cycles first, since it is the current most hyped bull market asset. First we will check medium term daily Gold data 1975 until 2025, we will look for his cycles < 3 years. You see there is many cycles detected. I choose only Ray's cycles. None of this shows consistent, correlated cycle to Gold price. Maybe his first 50 week cycle (350d) exist with 9 win and 5 loss, but will you trade this 0.7% correlation 🤣 Let's also check long term Gold cycles, I have monthly gold data from 1790 until 2025, so 235 years data. I see 7.74y cycle, maybe it is within the Orb (7.16y - 8.5y) from Rays expected 7.83y cycle, but it is also poor quality and currently inverted negative cycle. Do you really want to trade based on 'static cycle from a book' with 9 win and 12 loss ? Maybe the 12.1 year Gold cycle is strongest. Why this is not in Ray's book list ? ---------------------------- Ok, let us also check Copper, since I know it has better cycles then Gold. In fact, trading Gold is really a dumb idea in my opinion since the Gold cycle are highly variable compared to other assets. Here is Ray's list. I have medium term data for Copper, daily from 1988 until 2025. It is enough to test his first cycles. I put Rays cycles, not very good if you simply use static cycle in a book. How about if we also tune the amount of overtone and backtest period on Rays cycle, to improve Sorry, still not very good. Reader paying attention might notice 46.7m is within "Orb" large margin for error (39m to 54m), but others are totally useless and there is much better cycle we can find ourself. How about instead we just use recommendation by Timing Solution for Copper. Of course 34d/155d is very good, but it is of course not even in this experts book. Why is this? Because short cycle is best for trading, but short cycle will soon expire so it cannot be used to sell your book. ---------------------------- I will give one last example for Rays book list. Here is Wheat. I use medium term daily data, 1972 until 2025. I really do not know what this author is talking about. These are poor quality cycle. Do you also see how many other cycle peak is detected "within Orb" 32m-52m (2.6y-4.3) range. Orb shows many possible cycles. Many possible excuses. Give me a break. Here is my Wheat cycle. 44.8m (within 32m-52m large Orb margin for error from Rays book list). It is better then most of his other 'recommendation' but I will still not trade with such weak 9% price correlation. Maybe you prefer my cycle, 62% price correlation. Maybe I shall sell some books, like Ray and Gann, instead of trading 🙂 and when I make mistake and want margin for error, I will invent term, such as Orb so you will not sue me.

What is the orb method and if Gann works, why did he die a poor man as proven by his estate sale.

No need to waste time with this software, you can just use free trial of Seasonax or Seasonal-Trader websites

Gann the magical trader nobody can understand. Alleged best trader of all time, when he dies in 1955 his total estate is valued at only 100,000 Convert to 2024 value, only 1.1M dollars, for the so called best trader in history who can predict every market 🤣 Nothing more needs to be said.

No idea what Mikula is using but suggest you try Timing Solution to replicate this.

This thread should really be closed. Anyone referring to this software should now refer to newer Timing Solution. https://indo-investasi.com/topic/92067-timingsolution-amp-nifty-updates-2/#comment-707067

🎄 Merry Christmas and wishing everyone a fantastic 2025 ! 🥳

2025 Forecast Webinar: 2025 Forecast report coming soon: https://www.ireallytrade.com/forecasts/ Anyone interested in group buy for the full PDF report ?

No, I am long time trader and indo member, I never heard of TopGold until you mention it Looks like giant referral marketing forum, let me guess, they offer you money to bring indo members to them but they offer nothing of value in terms of trading to us. If people want to use TopGold why they not just join it directly ?

Larry's 2025 report will be released soon, he uses Timing Solution and his future forecast speak for itself. https://www.ireallytrade.com/forecasts/ I think Cycle analysis does work, but as for Gann, I think it is mostly riddles and endless puzzles based on mystery and occult, with many trying to profit on the mystery, plus many more who spend 2+ years of their life trying to solve the endless riddles. Many who wasted years studying Gann can never admit to themself they wasted their time on the endless riddle so they keep trying to find it forever, like the lost gold pirate treasure. Even Larry says he gave up on Gann 🤣 So if you think you cracked the Gann code, then good for you, just remember, physics waves (all besides planets) will change over time and Gann's work is based on Cycles over 80 years ago so of course many of the same cycle no longer exist in 2024 any more. I recommend Timing Solution wave physics analysis of raw data and forget about Gann. Study raw data, not ancient mystery. Ty Kesk for sharing as always.

If you want automatic updates maybe you should pay for the software. Why are all these newcomers so demanding? Kesk is very generous with his time already!

Wait for updated copy after August 5, author is still finishing programming the new astro model.

Dear Admin, Long time member here. Look forward to your announcement. 😀

Hi xshot007, welcome to indo! Im sure you will find a lot of very helpful information to build your trading success here :-)

Hi blanc, welcome! NN is quite a rare trading method, are you a very good programmer? You may find a little information here but not a huge amount.